One of the big talking points in the media this week has been the widespread (although mostly on the internet) opposition to x-factor winner Alexandra Burke presumed Christmas number 1 with a cover of Hallelujah. Seeing as this blog is indeed on the internet I probably ought to be taking this opportunity to join in the general hatred of Simon Cowell, but unfortunately I can't bring myself to do that.
You see here's the thing, the main argument seems to be something on these lines. Hallelujah is a great song, that is special to an awful lot of people, so therefore it shouldn't be commercialised.
Now that's quite a good argument, but sadly the reality is that great songs are sometimes going to be butchered by later pop covers (case in point, the brilliance that is Axel F, destroyed forever by the evil that is the Crazy Frog). If songs are going to be covered you have to accept that some will be good and some will be bad, that's just how it is.
That is not to say that I won't be overjoyed if Jeff Buckley is propelled to the top of the charts, it's just that I'm not upset about x-factor winners singing good songs. The way I see it, I'd rather listen to a passable version of a great song than Shayne Ward warbling 'That's my goal' or some similar tripe.
You're more than welcome to disagree with me in the strongest possible terms via the comments box, but remember this, no covers means no Buckley version either. If I have to ignore an awful version of a song in order to hear a great version then that's a price I'm willing to pay.
On a similar (but festive) note I'd just like to point out that the best xmas number one ever was also a cover...that's right Only You by The Flying Pickets
Returning to Hallelujah, here's a quick run down of a few of the many versions that are out there on Youtube. I've trawled the internet so that you don't have to.
Leonard Cohen - The original, but probably not the best. Cohen delivers in his typical singing-talking hybrid. Though quite frankly he wrote the thing so he can do whatever the hell he likes.
Jeff Buckley - Minimalistic, guitar backed, epic length version. If you are an angst-ridden teen, as opposed to a screaming pop-idol loving teen this will probably be your favourite.
Alexandra Burke - Not as bad as people seem to think, Burke can certainly sing a bit and it's nice to hear a version with a bit more in the way of backing. Though Dermot O'Leary doesn't add much with his cameo and there appears to be a point at which Westlife would stand up if they were singing it. Definitely goes down hill in the second half.
Kate Voegele - Sounds not entirely disimilar to a female Jeff Buckley version, not quite as good as Jeff but miles better than Alexandra.
Imogen Heap - Short A-Capella version, certainly different, but loses marks since it was recorded for use in The OC.
Rufus Wainwright - Piano backed, this is my favourite...so there
KD Lang - Somewhere in the gap between Rufus and Jeff, theres even a string section in there somewhere...marvelous
So there you go, if you know another good version please let me know the link (no rick-rolling please lol)
Have a great Christmas, may you receive many hats
D
Thoughts on leaving teaching
14 years ago
